Top investment considerations for insurers 2025 

We identify the five considerations that we believe insurers should have front and center as they look ahead. 

In the intricate world of insurance, an effective balance between underwriting performance and investment returns is not just a necessity; it is a strategic advantage. This paper explores the nuanced interplay between these two critical components, illustrating how investment risk can act as a stabilizing force, particularly during economic downturns when underwriting results may falter under the weight of increased claims and diminished premium income. By diversifying their investment portfolios across a spectrum of asset classes, insurers can effectively cushion the impact of underwriting pressures, ensuring sustained profitability even in challenging times.

For yield-oriented investers, the exploration of credit instruments — public and private — reveals a treasure trove of yield opportunities that, when paired with traditional government securities, can provide improved returns. Insurers are encouraged to embrace a dynamic approach to risk-taking — one that continuously evaluates market conditions and economic indicators to fine-tune their investment strategies.

As the paper navigates the complexities of fluctuating interest rates, particularly in a falling rate environment, it emphasizes the critical need for insurers to reassess their strategic asset allocation. By capitalizing on potential yields while deftly managing risks across various economic scenarios, insurers can position themselves for success. The focus on income generation and diversification emerges as a guiding principle, empowering insurers to navigate the ever-evolving landscape of portfolio positioning.

Our discussion further extends to the burgeoning realm of private market investments, spotlighting the innovative emergence of semi-liquid and evergreen fund structures. These investment vehicles not only offer insurers enhanced flexibility but also alleviate operational challenges, all while underscoring the necessity for rigorous due diligence and robust risk management frameworks.

In an era of heightened regulatory scrutiny, we examine the implications of the Prudent Person Principle (PPP), which mandates that insurers prioritize security, quality, liquidity, and profitability in their investment strategies. To thrive in this environment, insurers must elevate their governance frameworks, ensuring they are equipped to manage the complexities and risks associated with private market investments.

We also touch on the growing importance of climate considerations in the insurance sector. As regulatory frameworks continue to develop, insurers are increasingly encouraged to consider climate-related factors in their investment and risk management practices. 

Top considerations for insurers 2025

Download the report to learn how insurers can optimize their portfolio in 2025 and beyond.

Mercer investments and retirement consulting: How we can help

Whether you’re an employer, institutional investor, nonprofit organization, financial intermediary or family office, Mercer investments and retirement consulting aims to help you develop an investment solutions strategy unique to your situation, as well as provide the service and support you need.
  • Implementation and OCIO

    We can help you define, develop and implement your investment strategy by addressing areas such as governance, risk, sustainability and diversification. We flex our services to suit your needs and help you achieve your investment goals.
  • Sustainable investments 

    We help you build a sustainable investment strategy that integrates environmental, social and governance (ESG) considerations; diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) factors and seeks an optimal mix between positive change and favorable returns.
  • Alternative investments

    Leveraging our existing relationships with hundreds of asset managers around the world, we can help you identify and source new investment strategies, opportunities, ideas and innovations across private markets and hedge funds. 
  • Strategic research 

    Become a member of the MercerInsight® Community today to get access to strategic research from hundreds of thought leaders around the world, including Mercer and third-party publishers. It’s complimentary and easy to join.
  • Asset manager research 

    By subscribing to MercerInsight®, an alliance with eVestment, you can gain access to data, analytics and our forward-looking research on asset managers and thousands of investment strategies across both public and private markets. 
  • Managing investment risk

    Our Mercer Sentinel team can help you conduct due diligence and mitigate operational risks across your portfolios and strategies. We assess asset managers, custodians and other service providers to help you deliver on your governance objectives.

Related solutions

Related insights